IN DEFENCE OF SCIENCE

‘Science is a know-all creed!’

WRONG! Just as politicians like to

misrepresent the policies of their

opponents, some Believers (Choosers)

like to portray Science as a cocky,

know-all creed.

They couldn’t be more wrong.

 

No Scientist would ever claim

that Science knows everything.

Anyone who does Scientific research knows that it usually produces more questions than answers!

 

Scientists are sceptical about everything, including the ‘accepted wisdom’. They harbour a precious questioning doubtfulness which drives them to seek evidence and, if it contradicts the established position, they are prepared to revise their previously held opinions. Witness what happened when Einstein’s Theory improved upon Newton’s1. Some religious people find this attitude hard to comprehend being used to a simple, fixed, certain and ‘unchanging’2 doctrine that’s set down in black and white in some venerable book.

 

Footnotes

1. To clarify, Newton was not proved3 wrong by Einstein, his description of gravity is still good enough to enable us to accurately send spacecraft to rendezvous with the moons of Neptune. Although it’s a different way of looking at things, Einstein’s Relativity Theory is a only small improvement over Newton when calculations involving distances beyond the solar system or speeds approaching that of light are involved.

 

2. Although some religious people like to portray their doctrine as unchanging truths, the reality is the reverse. Unsurprisingly, with books written centuries ago when mankind really understood very little, some of the opinions (because that’s all they are) expressed have turned out to be embarrassingly wrong. Pope John Paul II had to admit the church was wrong about insisting that the Sun goes round the Earth and the Catholic church has recently abandoned the concept of “limbo”;

many in the church felt the idea was

outdated and caused undue worry for

parents. Before he was made Pope,

Benedict XVI said, ‘Limbo was just a

‘theological concept’ after all’!

Does that mean it had just been

made up?

 

3. I don’t like the word “prove” see here

Next >>>

<<< Back

To: Science Works!      Next >>>

<<< Back

15

15

Benedict XVI

Click here for worksheet on this page

MEDICAL MYSTERIES

The Human body is a very complex organism.

It’s only recently, since we gained an understanding of Chemistry and Physics, that we have been able to design the tools to begin to study ourselves.  Even so, Scientists have made some remarkable breakthroughs. In the West we live almost twice as long as we did a century ago and people are in such good condition in their sixties that it is spoken of as the ‘new forties’.

 

Yes, there are exceptions that Science cannot explain yet. Such as patients who were told they can only expect to live a few months and are still alive years later. Well, if you were a Doctor with evidence of a terminal disease and you had to estimate your patient’s life expectancy, which side would you prefer to err on? If you said ten years and they died in two months you might get sued!

 

One recent story reported a baby, stillborn in the opinion of the doctors, who the mother cuddled ‘back to life’. It’s a very heartwarming tale but much more likely that the doctors, being error prone humans, didn’t notice the infant’s imperceptible life signs. If there are only a few cases which contradict a large body of evidence we have to decide whether it is a ‘miracle’ or if there is a more plausible rational explanation.

 

The other accusation I hear is that Science cannot explain everything. TRUE!

 

But, come on, make up your minds  -  you can’t accuse Science of being know-all and not knowing all!

 

Scientists recognise that much needs to be discovered and are working on it! That’s the purpose of the Large Hadron Collider at Cern, amongst many other research programmes.

 

In particular, some people say Science cannot explain feelings like love. I say the word missing from that claim is ‘yet’! Recent research, using new instruments which enable the study of the living, thinking brain, is getting pretty close!

 

Science is not merely the best method for finding out, it’s the only one that works!

 

Watch this space!

THE UNEXPLAINED (CUE SPOOKY MUSIC!)

Click to go to page: 1 2 2a 3 3a 3b 4 5 5a 6 6a 7 8 8a 8b 8c 8ca 8cb 8d 8e 9 9a 10

11 11a 11b 11c 12 12a 13 13a 13b 14 15 16 17 18 19 19a 20 21 22 23 23a 24